HP Color LaserJet Pro M451dn M451 Laser Printer Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The hp color laserjet pro m451dn m451 laser printer is a sturdy desktop unit designed for color output and network connectivity. It supports duplex printing and duplex scanning within a footprint that measures 19.1 inches wide and 12.7 inches high. You get reliable two-sided document processing in a compact size that fits standard office desks. This model connects via USB and network ports for stable wired performance.
You might look for hp color laserjet pro m451dn m451 laser printer alternatives if you need wireless mobility, a different paper size, or a multifunction design. The selected 6 alternatives share key specs like color laser technology or duplex capabilities. Some options offer wireless connectivity for greater flexibility. Others provide A3 paper support or integrated faxing. These picks were chosen because their specifications overlap with the original model, giving you clear choices based on your specific office requirements.
Our top pick: HP Color LaserJet Pro M451 Duplex Color Printer.
How these picks differ
Brother INKvestment Tank All-in-One Printer
The Brother MFC-J4355DW uses inkjet technology rather than the laser engine found in the M451. It offers a smaller footprint at 17.1 inches wide and includes fax capabilities, which the M451 lacks. While it supports wireless connectivity and duplex scanning, it is best suited for low-volume color tasks. You should choose this if you need a budget-friendly multifunction device for light office use. The trade-off is that inkjet systems may have higher long-term costs per page compared to toner-based laser printers. It fits users who prioritize faxing and scanning over high-speed document processing.
Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC A3 Color MFP
The Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC supports A3 paper sizes, a capability the M451 does not have. It is designed for high-volume environments with a scan speed of 45 ppm. This model focuses on wired networking and lacks wireless features, making it less flexible for mobile users. You would pick this alternative if your team requires large-format color output and fast scanning speeds. The M451 is better for standard A4 offices needing wireless or USB connectivity. The Toshiba is a robust choice for heavy-duty tasks but requires a dedicated network setup and more space for larger paper formats.
Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color Laser Printer
The Canon imageCLASS LBP632Cdw is a print-only device, meaning it lacks the scanning and copying functions of the M451. It emphasizes wireless connectivity and mobile printing for home offices. At 17 inches wide, it is slightly narrower than the M451. You should select this if you only need color laser printing and want to save space and money by omitting multifunction features. It supports duplex printing and wireless scanning capabilities in its attributes, but the device itself does not include a scanner unit. This makes it a focused solution for users who already have a separate scanning device.
Epson EcoTank ET-4950 All-in-One Printer
The Epson EcoTank ET-4950 is an inkjet all-in-one that uses refillable tanks instead of toner cartridges. It offers wireless connectivity and duplex scanning, similar to the M451. This model is ideal for high-volume color printing where low ink costs are a priority. It is smaller and lighter than the M451, making it suitable for homes or small offices. You should choose this if you want to avoid cartridge management and frequent toner replacements. The trade-off is that inkjet technology may not match the speed or durability of laser printers for heavy office document processing. It is best for frequent color printing without the need for faxing.
Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color All-in-One Laser Printer
The Canon imageCLASS MF753Cdw is a wireless color laser all-in-one that includes faxing, which the M451 does not support. It offers mobile app control and fast color output for teams needing multifunction capabilities. At 18.2 inches long, it is longer than the M451. You should pick this if you require faxing and wireless convenience in a laser printer. It provides duplex scanning and printing similar to the M451 but adds fax functionality. The larger footprint may be a constraint for smaller desks. This model is best for users who need a comprehensive office solution with mobile integration and fax support.
HP Color LaserJet Pro Wireless All-in-One
The HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301sdw is a wireless all-in-one with an automatic document feeder. It offers duplex scanning and printing like the M451 but adds wireless convenience. At 16.5 inches wide, it is narrower than the M451. You should choose this if you need wireless connectivity and an ADF for batch scanning. It is suitable for small offices prioritizing wireless mobility over the M451's network ports. The M451 supports USB and network connections, while this model focuses on wireless. It is a practical alternative for users who want similar HP laser quality with added wireless features and an ADF for efficient document handling.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
HP Color LaserJet Pro M451 Duplex Color Printer
Best for: two-sided color network printing and scanning
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Color
- Connectivity
- USB, Network
- Features
- Duplex Printing
- Dimensions
- 15.9 × 19.1 × 12.7 inches
View on Amazon: HP Color LaserJet Pro M451 Duplex Color Printer Affiliate link
This renewed color laser printer provides two-sided output for your shared or personal workspace. You get automatic duplex printing alongside duplex scanning, driven through standard USB and wired network ports. Its footprint measures 19.1 inches wide by 15.9 inches long, making it suitable if you need reliable color documentation across everyday office network setups.
Pros
- Duplex printing and duplex scanning capability
- Standard USB and network connections
- Color laser print technology
- Light Gray and Black casing
Cons
- Limited 90-day warranty coverage
- Wide 19.1-inch footprint requires substantial desk space
Good fit if
- You need both duplex printing and duplex scanning in a color laser machine.
- You connect your office equipment directly using USB or network lines.
Skip if
- You need a warranty period longer than 90 days.
- You have limited workspace that cannot accommodate a 19.1-inch wide unit.
Verdict: HP Color LaserJet Pro Duplex Laser Printer suits office environments that require dedicated network color printing with double-sided document processing. It gives you duplex scanning and printing within a sturdy desktop footprint.
Brother INKvestment Tank All-in-One Printer
Best for: Low-volume color faxing
- Print Technology
- Inkjet
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- All-in-One
- Supported Functions
- Print, copy, scan, fax
- Print Speed
- Up to 20 ppm black / 19 ppm color
- Connectivity
- Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct, USB
View on Amazon: Brother INKvestment Tank All-in-One Printer Affiliate link
This Brother MFC-J4355DW is a wireless color inkjet all-in-one. It prints up to 20 ppm in black and 19 ppm in color. The unit supports automatic duplex printing and connects via Wi-Fi or USB. You get print, scan, copy, and fax functions. The INKvestment Tank system includes starter cartridges for lower running costs. It suits small offices needing versatile color output.
Pros
- Prints up to 20 ppm black and 19 ppm color
- Automatic two-sided printing saves paper
- Includes print, scan, copy, and fax functions
- Supports Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct, and USB connectivity
Cons
- Slower print speed than laser competitors on this list
- Inkjet technology may have higher long-term cost per page
- Starter cartridges provide limited page yields
Good fit if
- You need fax capability in a compact device
- You print color documents occasionally
- You want automatic duplex printing
Skip if
- You require high-volume laser speed
- You prefer toner over ink cartridges
- You need A3 paper support
Verdict: Brother MFC-J4355DW Wireless Inkjet fits users who need fax and color scanning in a small footprint. It is a practical pick for low-volume color tasks.
Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC A3 Color MFP
Best for: High-volume A3 color printing and scanning
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- Multifunction
- Connectivity
- Network
- Duplex Printing
- Auto Duplex
- Wide Format
- A3/A4
View on Amazon: Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC A3 Color MFP Affiliate link
The Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC is a color laser multifunction copier built for high-volume office environments. It supports both A3 and A4 paper sizes, making it versatile for larger documents. You get a print speed of 45 pages per minute, which matches its scan speed. It includes auto duplex printing and scanning, plus copy functionality. This unit connects via USB and network cables, ensuring stable performance for shared office workflows.
Pros
- 45 ppm print and scan speed
- Supports A3 and A4 paper sizes
- Auto duplex printing and scanning
- Network connectivity option
Cons
- Limited to USB and wired network connections
- No wireless Wi-Fi capability listed
- Single-function scanner without fax
Good fit if
- You need to print or scan A3-sized documents
- You require high-speed 45 ppm output for busy offices
- You prefer stable wired network connections over wireless
Skip if
- You need wireless Wi-Fi connectivity
- You only print standard A4 letter-size documents
- You require a compact desktop unit
Verdict: The Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC A3 Color MFP fits teams that need fast A3 color output and reliable wired networking. It is not suitable for users who require wireless mobility or smaller paper formats.
Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color Laser Printer
Best for: Home offices needing wireless color printing only
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- Single-function (print only)
- Supported Functions
- Print Speed
- 22 ppm (color and black)
- Connectivity
- Wireless
View on Amazon: Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color Laser Printer Affiliate link
The Canon imageCLASS LBP632Cdw is a single-function wireless color laser printer designed for home offices. It prints up to 22 pages per minute with automatic duplex printing. The unit includes a 250-sheet standard cassette and a multipurpose tray. It supports mobile printing and Chromebook compatibility. This model suits users who need reliable color output without scanning or copying features.
Pros
- Automatic 2-sided printing reduces paper waste
- Wireless connectivity for mobile and Chromebook devices
- Prints up to 22 pages per minute
- ENERGY STAR and EPEAT Silver certified
Cons
- Single-function design lacks scanning or copying
- Slower print speed than competing multifunction units
- Only includes a 1-year warranty
Good fit if
- You only need printing and no scanning
- You require wireless mobile printing support
- You want automatic duplex printing
Skip if
- You need a multifunction device with scanning
- You require faster print speeds than 22 ppm
- You prefer a longer warranty period
Verdict: Canon imageCLASS LBP632Cdw Wireless Color Laser is a focused print-only solution for home users who value wireless convenience and duplex printing over multifunction capabilities.
Epson EcoTank ET-4950 All-in-One Printer
Best for: High-volume color printing without cartridges
- Print Technology
- Inkjet
- Print Output
- Color
- Supported Functions
- Print, Copy, Scan, Fax
- Print Speed
- 18 black/9 color ISO ppm
- Connectivity
- Wireless
- Duplex Printing
- Auto duplex
View on Amazon: Epson EcoTank ET-4950 All-in-One Printer Affiliate link
The Epson EcoTank ET-4950 is a wireless color inkjet all-in-one designed for high-volume printing without cartridges. It delivers 18 pages per minute in black and 9 pages per minute in color. The system includes enough ink for up to 6,600 black or 5,500 color pages. It features auto duplex printing, scanning, copying, and faxing. This printer suits users who want to avoid frequent cartridge replacements and need reliable wireless connectivity.
Pros
- Cartridge-free ink tank system with high-capacity bottles
- Prints up to 6,600 black or 5,500 color pages from included ink
- Auto duplex printing and scanning for two-sided documents
- Supports faxing, copying, and wireless scanning
- Zero warmup time for faster first prints
Cons
- Print speed is slower than the laser alternatives on this list
- Inkjet technology may not match the durability of laser toner
- No wired Ethernet port listed in specifications
Good fit if
- You print high volumes of color documents regularly
- You want to eliminate the cost and hassle of buying cartridges
- You need wireless printing and scanning capabilities
Skip if
- You require the fastest possible print speeds for large offices
- You prefer laser technology for better moisture resistance
- You need a wired network connection for stability
Verdict: Epson EcoTank ET-4950 Wireless All-in-One is a practical choice for users who prioritize low ink costs and high page yields over raw speed. It fits homes or small offices that print frequently in color and want to avoid cartridge management.
Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color All-in-One Laser Printer
Best for: Fast color printing with fax and mobile support
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- Multifunction (all-in-one)
- Supported Functions
- Print, scan, copy, fax
- Print Speed
- 35 ppm (bw / color, letter)
- Connectivity
- Wireless
View on Amazon: Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color All-in-One Laser Printer Affiliate link
The Canon imageCLASS MF753Cdw is a wireless 4-in-1 color laser all-in-one printer. It prints up to 35 pages per minute with automatic duplexing. The unit includes a scanner, copier, and fax function. Paper handling features a 250-sheet cassette and a 50-sheet automatic document feeder. It supports mobile printing via the Canon PRINT Business app. This model suits offices needing fast color output and fax capabilities.
Pros
- Prints up to 35 pages per minute in black and color
- Automatic two-sided printing and one-pass scanning
- Includes fax, scan, and copy functions
- High capacity toner options available
- ENERGY STAR Certified and EPEAT Silver rated
Cons
- Standard paper capacity is 300 sheets total
- Requires optional cassette for expanded storage
- No wired Ethernet connectivity listed in data
Good fit if
- You need a fast color laser printer with fax support
- You want automatic two-sided printing and scanning
- You prefer mobile printing via Canon PRINT Business
Skip if
- You require built-in wired Ethernet connectivity
- You need high standard paper capacity without add-ons
- You only need black and white printing
Verdict: The Canon imageCLASS MF753Cdw Wireless Color Laser AIO fits teams that need faxing and fast color output. It works best for users who value automatic duplexing and mobile app control.
HP Color LaserJet Pro Wireless All-in-One
Best for: small offices needing wireless color printing with an ADF
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- All-in-One
- Supported Functions
- Print, scan, copy
- Print Speed
- 26 ppm
- Connectivity
- Wireless
View on Amazon: HP Color LaserJet Pro Wireless All-in-One Affiliate link
The HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301sdw is a wireless all-in-one color laser printer designed for small teams. It delivers print speeds of 26 ppm in black and color. The unit includes an automatic document feeder for batch scanning and auto two-sided printing. Its compact footprint fits standard office spaces. You get print, scan, and copy functions in one device. This model suits users who need reliable color output and efficient document handling without a large machine.
Pros
- 26 ppm print speed for black and color documents
- Automatic document feeder for unattended scanning
- Auto two-sided printing to save paper
- Wireless connectivity for flexible placement
- Supports HP 218A and 218X toner cartridges
Cons
- 26 ppm speed is slower than the Toshiba 45 ppm alternative
- No wired Ethernet port listed in specifications
- Print output is limited to letter size, not A3
Good fit if
- You need an automatic document feeder for high-volume scanning
- You prefer wireless setup without network cables
- You require color laser printing for professional reports
Skip if
- You need fast A3 printing for large formats
- You require a wired Ethernet connection
- You want a printer with speeds over 40 ppm
Verdict: The HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301sdw offers solid color laser performance with a useful automatic document feeder. It fits small offices that prioritize wireless convenience and duplex scanning over raw speed.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | HP Color LaserJet Pro M451 Duplex Color Printer | Brother INKvestment Tank All-in-One Printer | Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC A3 Color MFP | Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color Laser Printer | Epson EcoTank ET-4950 All-in-One Printer | Canon imageCLASS Duplex Color All-in-One Laser Printer | HP Color LaserJet Pro Wireless All-in-One |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Print Technology | Laser | Inkjet | Laser | Laser | Inkjet | Laser | Laser |
| Print Output | Color | Color | Color | Color | Color | Color | Color |
| Printer Type | not stated | All-in-One | Multifunction | Single-function (print only) | not stated | Multifunction (all-in-one) | All-in-One |
| Supported Functions | not stated | Print, copy, scan, fax | not stated | Print, Copy, Scan, Fax | Print, scan, copy, fax | Print, scan, copy | |
| Print Speed | not stated | Up to 20 ppm black / 19 ppm color | not stated | 22 ppm (color and black) | 18 black/9 color ISO ppm | 35 ppm (bw / color, letter) | 26 ppm |
| Connectivity | USB, Network | Wi-Fi, Wi-Fi Direct, USB | Network | Wireless | Wireless | Wireless | not stated |
| Duplex Printing | not stated | Automatic | Auto Duplex | Automatic 2-sided printing | Auto duplex | Automatic 2-sided printing | not stated |
| Wide Format | not stated | not stated | A3/A4 | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Ink/Toner System | not stated | Tank | not stated | Toner 067 / 067 High-Capacity | Ink tank, cartridge-free | Toner 069 / 069 High Capacity | not stated |
| Features | Duplex Printing | Duplex Printing, Mobile Printing, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Duplex Printing, Scanner, Copier | Duplex Printing, Mobile Printing | Duplex Printing, Fax | Duplex Printing, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Duplex Printing |
| Use Case | not stated | not stated | not stated | Office, Home | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Scanner Type | not stated | Portable | not stated | Portable | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Scanning | not stated | Wireless Scanning | not stated | Wireless Scanning | Wireless Scanning | Wireless Scanning | Wireless Scanning |
| Compatibility | not stated | not stated | A4, A3 | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Duplex Scanning | Duplex | Duplex | Duplex | Duplex | Duplex | Duplex | Duplex |
| Scan Speed | not stated | not stated | 45 ppm | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | 15.9 × 19.1 × 12.7 inches | 13.5 × 17.1 × 7.1 inches | not stated | 16.5 × 17 × 11.3 inches | 13.7 × 14.8 × 9.4 inches | 18.2 × 16.8 × 17 inches | 16.5 × 13.4 × 16.5 inches |
| Weight | not stated | 19.6 pounds | not stated | 35.3 pounds | 16.1 pounds | 48.5 pounds | 37.7 pounds |
| Color | Light Gray/Black | White | Black | white | Black | white | White |
| Model | M451 | E2BRMFCJ4355DW | E-Studio 2505AC | 5159C003 | C11CL40201 | 5455C010 | 499Q3F#BGJ |
| Size | not stated | 1 | not stated | One Size | not stated | One Size | standard |
If you also evaluate additive manufacturing hardware, review longer lk5 pro 3d printer alternatives for separate build specifications.
Frequently asked questions
Which alternative offers the smallest footprint for a small office?
The Epson EcoTank ET-4950 is the most compact option listed. It measures 14.8 inches wide and 9.4 inches high. This size fits easily on limited desk space. It also provides wireless scanning and duplex printing. You get an all-in-one device without sacrificing too much room.
Do any alternatives support wireless connectivity like the M451dn does not?
Yes, several models include wireless networking capabilities. The Brother MFC-J4355DW, Canon imageCLASS LBP632Cdw, and Epson EcoTank ET-4950 all feature wireless connectivity. The Canon imageCLASS MF753Cdw and HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301sdw also support wireless connections. This allows you to print from mobile devices or across the network.
Which printer is best for high-volume A3 color tasks?
The Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC A3 Color MFP is designed for this need. It supports both A4 and A3 paper formats. It delivers a scan speed of 45 ppm for fast document processing. This machine fits teams requiring reliable wired networking and large format output capabilities.
Is there a wireless-only option without multifunction features?
The Canon imageCLASS LBP632Cdw is a print-only solution. It focuses on wireless convenience and duplex printing. It lacks scanning or copying functions. This makes it suitable for home users who value a smaller footprint and do not need multifunction capabilities.
Which alternative includes faxing capability?
The Brother MFC-J4355DW and Epson EcoTank ET-4950 both include fax features. The Canon imageCLASS MF753Cdw also supports faxing for teams that need this function. These models allow you to send and receive faxes directly from the device alongside scanning and printing tasks.
Which printer is best for duplex scanning?
All listed alternatives support duplex scanning. The HP Color LaserJet Pro M451, Brother MFC-J4355DW, Toshiba E-Studio 2505AC, Canon imageCLASS LBP632Cdw, Epson EcoTank ET-4950, Canon imageCLASS MF753Cdw, and HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301sdw all feature duplex scanning. This allows you to process two-sided documents efficiently.
Which model is the heaviest on the list?
The Canon imageCLASS MF753Cdw is the heaviest unit at 48.5 pounds. It measures 18.2 inches long and 17 inches high. This weight reflects its robust construction for high-volume color printing and faxing. It is designed for teams needing fast output and mobile app control.