Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5170 Wireless Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

Comparing Alternatives to the ET-5170

Epson EcoTank Wireless Color All-in-One

The Epson EcoTank ET-4800 shares the supertank ink system and wireless connectivity of the ET-5170, but it is significantly more compact. At 6.7 inches high and 11 pounds, it saves space compared to the larger, heavier ET-5170. Both models include an automatic document feeder and fax support. However, the ET-4800 lacks the ET-5170’s dedicated fax capabilities in some configurations and generally offers slower print speeds. You should choose this model if your office has limited desk space and does not require the highest volume throughput. It provides similar low-cost printing for moderate workloads without the bulk of the Pro series.

Epson WorkForce Pro Color All-in-One Inkjet

The Epson WorkForce Pro WF-4830 is a color all-in-one that prioritizes connectivity and faxing for small offices. Unlike the ET-5170’s supertank system, this model uses traditional cartridges, which may result in higher long-term costs for high-volume users. It supports wireless printing and includes an automatic document feeder and fax function. The WF-4830 is larger and heavier than the ET-5170, measuring 19.8 inches wide and weighing 24 pounds. It offers solid speed for moderate workloads but lacks the cartridge-free efficiency of the EcoTank line. Pick this printer if you need reliable faxing and color output in a traditional cartridge format without the bulk of a supertank system.

Epson EcoTank Pro All-in-One Supertank Printer

The Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5150 is very similar to the ET-5170, sharing the supertank system, wireless connectivity, and automatic document feeder. Both models support high-volume color printing and faxing. The ET-5150 is slightly larger, measuring 25.9 inches wide, compared to the ET-5170’s 14.8 inches. It maintains similar print speeds and features like duplex printing. This model is ideal for offices that need the same core functionality as the ET-5170 but have different space requirements or prefer the specific configuration of the ET-5150. The choice between them often comes down to specific feature sets or availability, as both are designed for busy environments requiring reliable color and fax capabilities.

Epson EcoTank All-in-One Supertank

The Epson EcoTank ET-4850 offers a more compact footprint than the ET-5170, measuring 10 inches high and weighing 14.8 pounds. It shares the supertank ink system, wireless connectivity, and automatic document feeder. However, it lacks Ethernet connectivity, relying solely on wireless for network connections. This makes it less suitable for offices that prioritize wired stability. The ET-4850 also supports automatic duplex printing and faxing, similar to the ET-5170. Choose this model for home offices or small teams that value wireless mobility and a smaller size over the wired Ethernet option and larger capacity of the Pro series. It provides efficient color printing for moderate workloads.

HP OfficeJet Pro Wireless All-in-One

The HP OfficeJet Pro 8139e differs from the ET-5170 by using traditional cartridges instead of a supertank system. It supports wireless printing, faxing, and automatic duplex printing. The HP model is designed for home offices and small businesses, offering fast speeds and color output. It lacks the high-volume efficiency of the Epson’s ink bottle system, which may lead to higher operating costs for heavy users. The 8139e is compact and includes an automatic document feeder. Select this printer if you prefer the HP ecosystem or need a reliable color all-in-one for moderate workloads without the complexity of a supertank system. It is a practical choice for users who prioritize ease of use and standard cartridge replacement.

Epson EcoTank All-in-One Supertank

The Epson EcoTank ET-4800 provides wired Ethernet connectivity alongside wireless support, unlike the ET-5170 which focuses on wireless and Ethernet but is positioned as a Pro model. This model uses the supertank system for low-cost printing and includes an automatic document feeder and faxing. It is smaller and lighter than the ET-5170, making it easier to place in tight spaces. However, it may lack some advanced features or speed of the Pro series. Choose this model if you need a reliable supertank printer with wired network stability for an office environment. It is suitable for users who prioritize connectivity options and cost-effective printing over the highest volume capabilities of the Pro series.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Epson EcoTank Pro All-in-One Supertank Printer

Best for: High-volume color printing offices

Print Output

Color

Printer Type

All-in-One

Supported Functions

Print, scan, copy, fax

Print Speed

Up to 17 black / 9.5 color ISO ppm

Connectivity

Wireless, Wi-Fi Direct, Ethernet

Ink/Toner System

Supertank

View on Amazon: Epson EcoTank Pro All-in-One Supertank Printer Affiliate link

The Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5170 is a wireless color all-in-one supertank printer built for high-volume output. It prints up to 17 pages per minute in black and 9.5 in color with no warmup time. The system includes auto duplex printing, a 250-sheet tray, and an automatic document feeder. It uses low-cost ink bottles to reduce waste. This model suits offices needing reliable, fast color printing with minimal ongoing costs.

Pros

• Prints up to 17 black and 9.5 color ISO pages per minute
• Includes automatic document feeder and auto two-sided printing
• Uses cartridge-free supertank system with low-cost replacement bottles
• Features PrecisionCore permanent printhead for durability

Cons

• Print speed is slower than color laser competitors
• Physical footprint is large at 14.8 inches wide
• Ink bottle capacity yields fewer color pages than black

Good fit if

• You need fast color printing without warmup delays
• You want to avoid buying expensive toner cartridges
• You require an automatic document feeder for scanning

Skip if

• You only print monochrome documents
• You have limited desk space for a large unit
• You need higher color print speeds than 9.5 ppm

Verdict: The Epson ET-5170 Supertank AIO is a robust choice for teams that print high volumes of color documents daily. Its supertank system and fast black speeds make it ideal for busy offices that want to cut ink costs.

2 Also great

Epson EcoTank Wireless Color All-in-One

Best for: Color printing without cartridges

Print Output

Color

Printer Type

All-in-One

Supported Functions

Print, copy, scan, fax

Connectivity

Wireless, Ethernet

Ink/Toner System

Tank

Features

Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax

View on Amazon: Epson EcoTank Wireless Color All-in-One Affiliate link

The Epson EcoTank ET-4800 is a wireless color all-in-one printer that eliminates cartridges with its high-capacity ink tank system. It prints, scans, and copies, featuring an automatic document feeder for batch tasks. Measuring 14.8 by 11.8 by 6.7 inches and weighing 11 pounds, it offers a compact footprint. This model suits users seeking reliable color output and reduced waste without the hassle of traditional ink cartridges.

Pros

• Cartridge-free EcoTank ink system
• Automatic document feeder included
• Wireless connectivity
• Color print and scan functions

Cons

• No built-in fax capability listed
• Heavier than monochrome laser alternatives
• Lacks mobile app support in data

Good fit if

• You need color printing without cartridges
• You require an automatic document feeder
• You want a compact wireless all-in-one

Skip if

• You need monochrome laser speed
• You require built-in faxing
• You prioritize mobile app control

Verdict: Epson EcoTank ET-4800 Wireless is a practical color all-in-one for offices that want to avoid cartridges and need an ADF, but it may not suit those who strictly need faxing or monochrome speed.

3 Also great

Epson WorkForce Pro Color All-in-One Inkjet

Best for: Small offices needing color and fax

Print Technology

Inkjet

Print Output

Color

Printer Type

All-in-One

Supported Functions

Print, copy, scan, fax

Print Speed

Up to 25 ppm

Connectivity

USB, Ethernet, Bluetooth LE, Wi-Fi

View on Amazon: Epson WorkForce Pro Color All-in-One Inkjet Affiliate link

The Epson Workforce Pro WF-4830 is a wireless color all-in-one inkjet printer designed for small offices. It prints up to 25 ppm in black and white and 12 ppm in color. The unit supports auto two-sided printing, copying, scanning, and faxing. With a 33,000-page monthly duty cycle, it handles moderate workloads. Connectivity includes Wi-Fi, Ethernet, and Bluetooth Low Energy for flexible setup.

Pros

• Prints 25 ppm black/white and 12 ppm color
• Auto two-sided print, copy, scan, and fax
• 33,000-page monthly duty cycle
• Wi-Fi, Ethernet, and Bluetooth Low Energy

Cons

• Larger footprint at 19.8 inches wide
• Heavier build at 24 pounds
• Slower color print speed than monochrome rivals

Good fit if

• You need color printing with fax support
• You want a wireless all-in-one for small teams
• You require a high monthly duty cycle

Skip if

• You need a compact desktop printer
• You only print black and white text
• You prioritize the fastest possible color speeds

Verdict: Epson Workforce Pro WF-4830 Color Inkjet suits small offices needing color output and faxing. It offers solid speed and connectivity for moderate workloads.

4 Also great

Epson EcoTank Pro All-in-One Supertank Printer

Best for: High-volume color faxing and scanning

Print Output

Color

Printer Type

All-in-One

Supported Functions

Print, scan, copy

Print Speed

17 black/9.5 color ISO ppm

Connectivity

Wireless, Ethernet

Duplex Printing

Auto 2-sided

View on Amazon: Epson EcoTank Pro All-in-One Supertank Printer Affiliate link

The Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5150 is a wireless color all-in-one supertank printer designed for high-volume business environments. It delivers print speeds of up to 17 pages per minute in black and 9.5 in color, with no warmup time. The system uses DURABrite ET pigment inks and includes an automatic document feeder. It supports print, scan, copy, and fax functions, making it a versatile tool for office workflows.

Pros

• Prints up to 17 black or 9.5 color ISO ppm
• No warmup time for fast first page out
• Includes automatic document feeder for scanning and copying
• Supports fax, print, scan, and copy functions
• Uses cartridge-free supertank ink system

Cons

• Large footprint measuring 25.9 inches wide
• Heavier build at 15 pounds
• Higher price point than standard EcoTank models

Good fit if

• You need fast color printing without warmup delays
• You require fax capabilities in an all-in-one device
• You want to reduce cartridge waste with supertank ink

Skip if

• You have limited desk space for a large printer
• You only need basic black-and-white printing
• You prefer a compact portable device

Verdict: The Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5150 Supertank Printer fits busy offices that need reliable color faxing and scanning. Its supertank system and fast speeds support high-volume daily tasks.

5

Epson EcoTank All-in-One Supertank

Best for: Wireless home offices needing fax and duplexing

Print Output

Color

Printer Type

All-in-One

Supported Functions

Print, scan, copy, fax

Print Speed

Up to 15.5 ppm black / 8.5 ppm color

Connectivity

Wireless

Ink/Toner System

Supertank

View on Amazon: Epson EcoTank All-in-One Supertank Affiliate link

The Epson EcoTank ET-4850 is a wireless color all-in-one supertank printer. It prints up to 15.5 pages per minute in black and 8.5 pages per minute in color. The unit supports automatic two-sided printing and includes an automatic document feeder. It offers mobile printing via the Epson Smart Panel app. This model suits users who need fax capabilities and reliable wireless connectivity for home or small office tasks.

Pros

• Prints up to 15.5 ppm in black and 8.5 ppm in color
• Includes automatic document feeder for multi-page scanning
• Supports automatic two-sided printing to save paper
• Offers wireless scanning and mobile printing options

Cons

• Color print speed is slower at 8.5 ppm
• Lacks built-in Ethernet port for wired networking
• Heavier build at 14.8 pounds

Good fit if

• You need a wireless printer with fax support
• You want to print double-sided pages automatically
• You prefer cartridge-free supertank ink systems

Skip if

• You require high-speed color printing above 8.5 ppm
• You need a wired Ethernet connection for stability
• You prefer a compact monochrome laser printer

Verdict: The Epson ET-4850 Wireless Color Supertank is a practical choice for users who need faxing and automatic duplexing. It fits small offices that value wireless mobility over wired speed.

6 Best budget

HP OfficeJet Pro Wireless All-in-One

Best for: Home offices needing color and fax features

Print Technology

Inkjet

Print Output

Color

Printer Type

All-in-One

Supported Functions

Print, scan, copy, fax

Print Speed

20 ppm

Connectivity

Wireless, Ethernet

View on Amazon: HP OfficeJet Pro Wireless All-in-One Affiliate link

This HP OfficeJet Pro 8139e is a color inkjet all-in-one designed for home offices. It prints up to 20 pages per minute and supports wireless, Ethernet, and mobile connectivity. The unit includes automatic duplex printing and an automatic document feeder for multi-page tasks. You get print, scan, copy, and fax functions in one compact device. It weighs 18 pounds and measures 18.1 inches wide.

Pros

• Prints up to 20 pages per minute
• Automatic duplex printing and scanning
• Includes automatic document feeder
• Supports wireless, Ethernet, and mobile printing

Cons

• Uses standard ink cartridges instead of a tank system
• Heavier and bulkier than monochrome laser alternatives
• Lacks the high-yield cartridge efficiency of laser models

Good fit if

• You need color output for home office documents
• You require fax capabilities for business communication
• You want automatic two-sided printing to save paper

Skip if

• You only print black and white text
• You prefer the lower cost-per-page of laser printers
• You need a compact device under 15 pounds

Verdict: The HP OfficeJet Pro 8139e All-in-One suits home users who need color printing and faxing. It offers fast speeds and automatic duplexing for busy workflows.

7 Best premium

Epson EcoTank All-in-One Supertank

Best for: offices needing wired Ethernet and faxing

Print Technology

Inkjet

Print Output

Color

Printer Type

All-in-One

Supported Functions

Print, Copy, Scan, Fax

Print Speed

Up to 10.0 ppm

Connectivity

USB, Wi-Fi, Ethernet, Wi-Fi Direct

View on Amazon: Epson EcoTank All-in-One Supertank Affiliate link

This Epson EcoTank ET-4800 is a wireless color all-in-one printer designed for office use. It features print, copy, scan, and fax functions. The device includes an automatic document feeder for handling multi-page tasks. It connects via Wi-Fi and wired Ethernet. The tank system provides high page yields, supporting up to 4,500 black or 7,500 color pages per ink set. It prints at speeds up to 10 ppm in black.

Pros

• Includes wired Ethernet for stable network connections
• Built-in automatic document feeder for batch scanning
• Supports faxing alongside print, copy, and scan

Cons

• Lacks automatic two-sided printing capability
• Black print speed is limited to 10 ppm
• Color print speed is limited to 5 ppm

Good fit if

• You need reliable wired Ethernet connectivity
• You require fax capabilities for your office
• You want to scan multi-page documents automatically

Skip if

• You need automatic double-sided printing
• You require high-speed color printing
• You prefer laser technology over inkjet

Verdict: The Epson ET-4800 Wireless All-in-One suits users who prioritize wired network stability and faxing. It is a solid option for offices needing an automatic document feeder, though its speed and lack of duplex printing limit its appeal for high-volume dynamic workflows.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• razer hammerhead true wireless pro alternatives
• arlo pro wireless security camera alternatives