6 Best Alternatives to the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 (2026)
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The HP Smart Tank Plus 651 Wireless All-in-One offers color ink tank printing with fax support and wireless connectivity. You might look for hp smart tank plus 651 alternatives if you need monochrome output, a different size, or a laser engine instead of an ink tank system. This list covers 6 options that share core features like wireless printing, scanning, copying, and faxing. Each alternative overlaps with the original in function, allowing you to compare specific specs like print speed, duplex capabilities, or physical dimensions.
Some picks prioritize high-volume monochrome speed, while others focus on compact design or color laser versatility. You can choose based on your need for automatic document feeding, touch screens, or specific connectivity options. All listed models support mobile printing and include fax functions. This guide helps you compare these specifications directly. You can find the best match for your home or office environment by reviewing the detailed data for each device.
Our top pick: HP Smart Tank Plus Wireless All-in-One.
How Alternatives Compare to HP 651
Canon imageCLASS MF465dw Monochrome All-in-One
The Canon imageCLASS MF465dw uses monochrome laser technology, so it prints only black and white pages. This contrasts with the HP 651, which produces color output via an ink tank system. The Canon model prints up to 42 pages per minute, which is significantly faster than typical ink tank speeds. It also weighs 34.4 pounds, making it much heavier than the 10.3-pound HP unit. You should choose this alternative if you need rapid document printing and do not require color. It supports duplex scanning and faxing, matching the HP 651 in those areas. The trade-off is the lack of color capability.
Canon MegaTank G4270 All-in-One
The Canon MegaTank G4270 is a wireless ink tank printer like the HP 651, but it lacks automatic duplex printing. It shares the fax support and automatic document feeder found on the HP model. This Canon unit is slightly larger in width at 16.4 inches compared to the HP 651 at 14.7 inches. It weighs 15.8 pounds, which is heavier than the HP 651. You might prefer this option if you want a budget-friendly color ink tank solution with fax capabilities. The main difference is the absence of double-sided printing, which the HP 651 also lacks, but the Canon offers a different physical footprint and weight profile for your office space.
Epson EcoTank Pro Color All-in-One
The Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5180 is a large wireless all-in-one that supports color printing and faxing, similar to the HP 651. However, it is designed for higher-volume office use. This Epson model is larger, measuring 14.8 inches in width and 13.6 inches in height, compared to the HP 651. It weighs 16.1 pounds, making it heavier than the HP unit. Both devices include an automatic document feeder and wireless connectivity. You should pick this alternative if you need a more robust build for a busy office environment. The key distinction is the Epson's larger size and professional-grade positioning, whereas the HP 651 is sized for home use.
Canon MegaTank GX7120 Touchscreen Printer
The Canon MegaTank GX7120 is a wireless color ink tank printer with an automatic document feeder and fax support, matching the HP 651. Its standout feature is the physical touch screen, which the HP 651 does not specify having. This Canon model is smaller in length at 15.8 inches compared to the HP 651 at 17.7 inches. It weighs 28.6 pounds, which is nearly three times heavier than the HP unit. You might choose this printer if you prefer direct physical control over a touchscreen interface. The trade-off is the significant difference in weight and the inclusion of a touch screen for easier navigation.
Canon imageCLASS MF656Cdw All-in-One Laser
The Canon imageCLASS MF656Cdw is a wireless color laser printer, which differs from the HP 651 ink tank system. It supports color output, faxing, and duplex scanning, adding double-sided printing capability that the HP 651 lacks. This Canon unit is much larger and heavier, weighing 48.5 pounds compared to the HP 651 at 10.3 pounds. It measures 17.8 inches in width and 16.3 inches in height. You should select this alternative if you need automatic double-sided printing and scanning. The laser technology offers different maintenance needs, and the larger footprint requires more desk space than the compact HP 651.
Brother Compact Monochrome All-in-One Laser Printer
The Brother MFC-L2710DW is a compact monochrome laser printer, so it prints only black and white pages, unlike the color HP 651. It supports wireless scanning, faxing, and duplex printing, adding double-sided capabilities the HP 651 does not have. This Brother model weighs 26 pounds, which is heavier than the HP 651. It measures 16.1 inches in width and 10.7 inches in height. You might prefer this alternative if you prioritize wireless scanning and faxing in a monochrome laser device. The main difference is the output type, with the Brother focusing on text documents and the HP 651 providing color versatility.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
HP Smart Tank Plus Wireless All-in-One
Best for: Home users needing color ink tank printing
- Print Technology
- Ink tank
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- All-in-one
- Supported Functions
- Print, scan, copy, fax
- Connectivity
- Wireless, mobile printing
- Ink/Toner System
- Refillable ink tank, cartridge-free
The HP Smart Tank Plus 651 is a wireless color all-in-one printer designed for home use. It features a refillable ink tank system that supports print, scan, copy, and fax functions. The unit includes an automatic document feeder and mobile printing capabilities. It measures 14.7 inches wide and weighs 10.3 pounds. This model suits users seeking high-volume, low-cost printing with included ink.
Pros
- Refillable ink tank system for cartridge-free printing
- Supports color, scan, copy, and fax functions
- Includes automatic document feeder for batch scanning
- Enables wireless and mobile printing connectivity
Cons
- Prints in color only, not monochrome
- Scanner type listed as portable in attributes
- No data confirms a physical control display
Good fit if
- You need color printing for home documents
- You want to avoid buying replacement cartridges
- You require fax capabilities for your office
Skip if
- You only need black and white text
- You require a compact desktop footprint
- You prefer monochrome laser reliability
Verdict: HP Smart Tank Plus 651 Wireless All-in-One is a solid choice for home users who need color output and fax support without the hassle of cartridges. It fits well if you value wireless convenience and high page yields.
Canon imageCLASS MF465dw Monochrome All-in-One
Best for: High-volume monochrome office printing
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Monochrome
- Printer Type
- All-in-One
- Supported Functions
- Print, scan, copy, fax
- Print Speed
- 42 ppm
- Connectivity
- Wireless
View on Amazon: Canon imageCLASS MF465dw Monochrome All-in-One
The Canon imageCLASS MF465dw is a monochrome laser all-in-one printer designed for speed. It prints up to 42 pages per minute with a first page out time of approximately 5 seconds. You get print, scan, copy, and fax functions. The 50-sheet automatic document feeder handles multi-page tasks efficiently. With a 250-sheet standard tray and optional expansion, it supports high-volume office workflows.
Pros
- Prints up to 42 pages per minute
- First page out in approximately 5 seconds
- 50-sheet one-pass automatic document feeder
- Supports print, scan, copy, and fax
- Expandable paper capacity up to 900 sheets
Cons
- Monochrome output only
- No color printing capability
- Requires optional cassette for maximum capacity
Good fit if
- You need fast black and white document printing
- You require fax and scanning capabilities
- You handle high-volume office tasks
Skip if
- You need color printing
- You require a compact footprint under 16 inches
- You prefer ink tank technology
Verdict: The Canon imageCLASS MF465dw Monochrome Laser AIO fits busy offices needing rapid monochrome output and fax support. It suits teams prioritizing speed and document management over color versatility.
Canon MegaTank G4270 All-in-One
Best for: High-volume color printing with fax support
- Printer Type
- Multifunction (all-in-one)
- Supported Functions
- Print, copy, scan, fax
- Connectivity
- Wireless
- Duplex Printing
- Single-sided printing
- Ink/Toner System
- Supertank
- Features
- Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax
The Canon Megatank G4270 is a wireless all-in-one printer that supports print, copy, scan, and fax functions. It uses a supertank system to deliver up to 6,000 black and white pages or 7,700 color pages per ink set. This model includes an automatic document feeder for efficient scanning. It features a small 1.35-inch square LCD display. The unit measures 16.4 by 13.3 by 8.4 inches and weighs 15.8 pounds.
Pros
- Includes up to two years of ink
- High-yield supertank system for low cost per page
- Supports fax, copy, and scan functions
- Built-in automatic document feeder
Cons
- Single-sided printing only
- Small 1.35-inch LCD display
- Larger footprint than compact laser alternatives
Good fit if
- You need fax capability for business correspondence
- You want to minimize ongoing ink costs
- You require an automatic document feeder for bulk scanning
Skip if
- You need automatic two-sided printing
- You prefer a compact device under 15 pounds
- You only need monochrome printing
Verdict: Canon Megatank G4270 Wireless Supertank Printer suits users who prioritize low ink costs and fax support over duplex printing. It fits home offices needing high-volume color output.
Epson EcoTank Pro Color All-in-One
Best for: High-volume color office printing with fax
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- All-in-One
- Supported Functions
- Print, Scan, Copy, Fax
- Print Speed
- 17 black/9.5 color ISO ppm
- Connectivity
- Ethernet
- Duplex Printing
- Auto 2-sided
The Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5180 is a wireless color all-in-one designed for high-volume office use. It features a PrecisionCore permanent printhead and supports PCL/PostScript. Print speeds reach 17 pages per minute in black and 9.5 in color. The unit includes an automatic document feeder, fax capabilities, and auto two-sided printing. A 250-sheet paper tray and Ethernet connectivity round out its professional feature set.
Pros
- Cartridge-free ink system saves up to 80 percent on ink costs
- Prints up to 17 black and 9.5 color ISO pages per minute
- Includes automatic document feeder, fax, and auto two-sided printing
- PrecisionCore permanent printhead built for reliability in high-volume environments
Cons
- Larger footprint at 14.8 inches wide and 13.6 inches high
- Heavier build at 16.1 pounds compared to compact monochrome lasers
- No mention of mobile printing apps or Wi-Fi Direct in specs
Good fit if
- You need fast color output for business documents
- You want to avoid buying expensive toner cartridges
- You require fax and scanning features in one unit
Skip if
- You only print black and white text
- You need a compact printer for a small desk
- You rely on mobile app printing workflows
Verdict: Epson EcoTank Pro ET-5180 Wireless All-in-One is a robust color solution for offices that print high volumes. It fits teams that need faxing and scanning alongside fast, low-cost color output.
Canon MegaTank GX7120 Touchscreen Printer
Best for: Users who prefer physical touch screens
- Printer Type
- All-in-One
- Connectivity
- Wireless
- Ink/Toner System
- Tank
- Supported Functions
- Scan, Copy
- Features
- Automatic Document Feeder, Touch Screen, Scanner, Copier, Fax
- Scanning
- Auto Document Feeder
The Canon Megatank GX7120 is a compact, wireless all-in-one printer that includes up to two years of ink. It features a 2.7-inch LCD touch screen for intuitive operation and supports printing, copying, scanning, and faxing. The small footprint helps it fit into tight workspaces. It is a practical option for users who prioritize a tactile interface and included supplies over mobile app control.
Pros
- 2.7-inch LCD touch screen for direct control
- Includes up to two years of ink
- Compact size fits small workspaces
- Supports print, copy, scan, and fax
Cons
- No mobile app support listed
- Small 2.7-inch screen may feel limited
- No automatic duplex printing mentioned
Good fit if
- You prefer a physical touch screen over app control
- You need a compact printer for a small desk
- You want included ink supplies for immediate use
Skip if
- You require automatic two-sided printing
- You need mobile printing from your phone
- You want a larger display for easier reading
Verdict: Canon Megatank GX7120 Wireless All-in-One suits users who want a small, ready-to-use printer with a physical touch screen. It is a good fit for small offices that value included ink and direct device control.
Canon imageCLASS MF656Cdw All-in-One Laser
Best for: color laser printing with fax and scanning
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Color
- Printer Type
- Multifunction (all-in-one)
- Supported Functions
- Print, scan, copy, fax
- Print Speed
- 22 ppm (bw / color, letter)
- Connectivity
- Wireless
The Canon imageCLASS MF656Cdw is a wireless 4-in-1 color laser printer. It prints up to 22 pages per minute in both black and white. The device includes a 50-sheet automatic document feeder for one-pass duplex scanning. It supports auto two-sided printing and offers fax capabilities. This all-in-one unit suits offices needing color output and mobile printing via the Canon PRINT Business app.
Pros
- Prints up to 22 ppm in black and white
- Supports wireless connectivity for mobile devices
- Includes 50-sheet duplex automatic document feeder
- Offers fax functionality alongside print, scan, and copy
Cons
- Print speed is slower than the 24 ppm Canon MF455dw
- Color output requires higher toner costs than monochrome models
- Physical footprint is larger than compact monochrome printers
Good fit if
- You need reliable color laser printing for documents
- You require fax capabilities in your office setup
- You want automatic two-sided scanning for efficiency
Skip if
- You only need black and white printing
- You require a faster print speed than 22 ppm
- You prefer ink tank systems for lower cost per page
Verdict: The Canon MF656Cdw Wireless Color Laser fits teams needing color output and fax features in a compact wireless package. It is a solid choice for offices that prioritize versatility over maximum speed.
Brother Compact Monochrome All-in-One Laser Printer
Best for: wireless scanning and faxing
- Print Technology
- Laser
- Print Output
- Monochrome
- Printer Type
- All-in-One
- Connectivity
- Wireless
- Supported Functions
- Scan, Copy
- Features
- Duplex Printing, Mobile Printing, Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax
View on Amazon: Brother Compact Monochrome All-in-One Laser Printer
The Brother MFC-L2710DW is a compact wireless monochrome laser all-in-one printer. It includes print, scan, copy, and fax capabilities. The unit features an automatic document feeder and duplex scanning for efficient multi-page handling. Mobile printing support allows you to manage tasks from your devices. Its small footprint makes it suitable for tight workspaces.
Pros
- Wireless connectivity for network printing
- Automatic document feeder for batch scanning
- Duplex scanning capability
- Built-in fax function
Cons
- Monochrome output only
- No color printing capability
- Limited to black and white documents
Good fit if
- You need reliable wireless scanning
- You require fax functionality
- You print mostly black and white text
Skip if
- You need color printing
- You require large format output
- You prefer ink tank systems
Verdict: Brother MFC-L2710DW Compact Monochrome Laser is a practical choice for users who prioritize wireless scanning and faxing in a compact monochrome laser device.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | HP Smart Tank Plus Wireless All-in-One | Canon imageCLASS MF465dw Monochrome All-in-One | Canon MegaTank G4270 All-in-One | Epson EcoTank Pro Color All-in-One | Canon MegaTank GX7120 Touchscreen Printer | Canon imageCLASS MF656Cdw All-in-One Laser | Brother Compact Monochrome All-in-One Laser Printer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Print Technology | Ink tank | Laser | not specified | not specified | not specified | Laser | Laser |
| Print Output | Color | Monochrome | not specified | Color | not specified | Color | Monochrome |
| Printer Type | All-in-one | All-in-One | Multifunction (all-in-one) | All-in-One | All-in-One | Multifunction (all-in-one) | All-in-One |
| Supported Functions | Print, scan, copy, fax | Print, scan, copy, fax | Print, copy, scan, fax | Print, Scan, Copy, Fax | not specified | Print, scan, copy, fax | not specified |
| Print Speed | not specified | 42 ppm | not specified | 17 black/9.5 color ISO ppm | not specified | 22 ppm (bw / color, letter) | not specified |
| Connectivity | Wireless, mobile printing | Wireless | Wireless | Ethernet | Wireless | Wireless | Wireless |
| Duplex Printing | not specified | Automatic 2-sided printing | Single-sided printing | Auto 2-sided | not specified | Automatic 2-sided printing | not specified |
| First Page Out | not specified | Approximately 5 seconds | not specified | not specified | not specified | not specified | not specified |
| Ink/Toner System | Refillable ink tank, cartridge-free | Toner | Supertank | Cartridge-Free | Tank | Toner 067 / 067 High Capacity | not specified |
| Features | Mobile Printing, Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Duplex Printing, Mobile Printing, Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Automatic Document Feeder, Touch Screen, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Duplex Printing, Mobile Printing, Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax | Duplex Printing, Mobile Printing, Automatic Document Feeder, Scanner, Copier, Fax |
| Ideal For | Documents | Documents | Documents | Documents | Documents | Documents | not specified |
| Use Case | Home | Office, Home | not specified | not specified | not specified | not specified | not specified |
| Scanner Type | Portable | Portable | not specified | not specified | not specified | Portable | Portable |
| Scanning | Auto Document Feeder | Auto Document Feeder | Auto Document Feeder | Auto Document Feeder | Auto Document Feeder | Auto Document Feeder | Wireless Scanning |
| Duplex Scanning | not specified | Duplex | not specified | not specified | not specified | Duplex | Duplex |
| Auto Document Feeder | ADF | ADF | ADF | ADF | ADF | ADF | ADF |
| Dimensions | 17.7 × 14.7 × 7.8 inches | 18.1 × 16.6 × 14.8 inches | 13.3 × 16.4 × 8.4 inches | 13.7 × 14.8 × 13.6 inches | 15.8 × 16.2 × 12.4 inches | 18.2 × 17.8 × 16.3 inches | 15.7 × 16.1 × 10.7 inches |
| Weight | 10.3 pounds | 34.4 pounds | 15.8 pounds | 16.1 pounds | 28.6 pounds | 48.5 pounds | 26 pounds |
| Size | Medium | One Size | One Size | Large | Small | One Size | not specified |
| Color | White with Black Top | White | Black | White | White | White | Black |
| Model | 651 | 5951C005 | 5807C002 | ET-5180 | 6880C002 | 5158C002 | MFC-L27 10DW |
When planning your office network, review thirdreality smart hub gen2 plus alternatives to evaluate connection protocols and compatibility specifications.
Frequently asked questions
Which HP Smart Tank Plus 651 alternative is best for home use?
The HP Smart Tank Plus Wireless All-in-One remains the top choice for home users needing color ink tank printing. It supports faxing and mobile printing via wireless connectivity. This model includes an automatic document feeder and scanner. Its compact size fits well in home offices while providing high page yields without cartridge hassles.
Is there a faster monochrome alternative to the HP 651?
The Canon imageCLASS MF465dw Monochrome All-in-One offers high-speed monochrome output for busy environments. It prints up to 42 pages per minute, which is significantly faster than standard ink tank models. This device supports duplex scanning and faxing. It is ideal for teams prioritizing speed and document management over color versatility.
What is the best budget-friendly color tank printer alternative?
The Canon MegaTank G4270 All-in-One is the best budget option for high-volume color printing. It supports faxing and wireless connectivity for easy setup. This model includes an automatic document feeder and scanner. It is designed for users who prioritize low ink costs and color output over duplex printing capabilities in a home office setting.
Can I find a premium color laser alternative to the HP 651?
The Canon imageCLASS MF656Cdw All-in-One Laser is a strong premium choice for color laser printing. It supports duplex printing, mobile printing, and faxing via wireless connectivity. This device includes an automatic document feeder and scanner. It is a solid choice for offices that prioritize versatility and color output in a compact wireless package.
Does any alternative include a physical touchscreen for easier control?
The Canon MegaTank GX7120 Touchscreen Printer includes a physical touch screen for direct device control. This model supports wireless connectivity and faxing for home or small office use. It features an automatic document feeder and scanner. It is a good fit for users who prefer physical interfaces and value included ink with a small, ready-to-use design.
Which alternative is best for wireless scanning and faxing?
The Brother Compact Monochrome All-in-One Laser Printer is optimized for wireless scanning and faxing tasks. It supports duplex printing, mobile printing, and wireless scanning via an automatic document feeder. This monochrome laser device is practical for users who prioritize these specific features. It offers a compact footprint suitable for spaces where size and function are key.
Are there large capacity alternatives for high-volume office printing?
The Epson EcoTank Pro Color All-in-One is a robust solution for high-volume color office printing. It supports faxing, scanning, and wireless connectivity with an automatic document feeder. This large-sized device is designed for teams needing fast, low-cost color output. It fits well in offices that require extensive document handling alongside reliable color printing capabilities.